How to Sort Quilt Scraps by Size and Count What You Can Cut

By Chris, founder of QuiltLab••Updated •9 min read
Design TipsTutorial
Scale diagram comparing a two-and-a-half by ten-inch strip that fits four squares with a two-and-a-quarter-inch-wide rectangle that is too narrow

Measure the biggest clean rectangle in each scrap and sort by its narrow side, into a few groups that match the cuts your next pattern needs. A 2 1/2 x 10-inch strip goes with your 2 1/2-inch cuts. A 5-inch square can give you one 4 1/2-inch square or four 2 1/2-inch squares, but not both. Count what each group can give before you cut anything.

That's the point of sorting quilt scraps by size: knowing which pieces you can actually cut. A bin labeled "small scraps" can't tell you that. A short list of clean widths and lengths can. Below, we work through a made-up set of cotton scraps for a small study quilt. We haven't sewn it.

Sort for the pattern you're considering

For most quilters, the useful question is "Do these leftovers have enough for the units I want to make?" That's a smaller job than deciding what size to cut every future scrap.

The American Patchwork & Quilting editors' organization guide ties sorting by size to patterns that repeat the same units. Bonnie Hunter's Scrap User's System, as HollyAnne Knight describes it in her scrap organization post at String & Story, goes further: Hunter trims scraps into squares, bricks and strips and stores them by color and size. Knight notes that quilters who love improv or foundation piecing may prefer to keep scraps untrimmed, and she's reluctant to keep anything smaller than 2 inches square. So you don't need to cut every piece today. Count first, and decide on cuts once you have a pattern.

Use a few temporary groups:

  • Ready squares: squares you've measured.
  • Wide pieces: wide enough for the larger cut you're considering.
  • Narrow strips and rectangles: good for smaller cuts or longer strips.
  • Other shapes: triangles, tapered pieces and odd fragments to look at separately.
  • Left out: wrong fiber, damaged, or too small for these cuts.

These groups are just for today's project. Keep each piece in one group, and give each group a letter so your list can refer to it.

Measure the clean rectangle inside the scrap

Press a scrap flat before you measure it. Look for selvage, holes, stains, fraying and earlier cuts that break up the useful area. An irregular scrap's widest and longest points can describe a rectangle that isn't really there.

For square cuts, find a sound rectangle that runs with the grain and measure its short and long sides. Don't count an L-shaped piece as its full outline, and don't add two separate sections together as if they were one.

A 2 1/4 x 6-inch rectangle holds 13 1/2 square inches of fabric. A 2 1/2-inch square needs only 6 1/4. The rectangle still can't give you that square: its 2 1/4-inch side is too short. Extra length doesn't fix a short width, which is why you sort by the narrow side.

If an edge needs squaring up, measure after you've allowed for it. A 2 1/2-inch scrap that's 2 3/8 inches wide once you trim off a frayed edge doesn't count for a 2 1/2-inch cut. Save it for a smaller job.

Check cut size against finished size

Check whether the pattern lists cut, unfinished or finished sizes. They mean different things.

With 1/4-inch seams on all four sides, a 4 1/2-inch cut square finishes at 4 inches. A four-patch made from four 2 1/2-inch cut squares measures 4 1/2 inches unfinished and 4 inches finished:

  • Across a row, two 2 1/2-inch squares add up to 5 inches.
  • The seam between them takes 1/2 inch, leaving 4 1/2 inches.
  • The outside seams take another 1/2 inch when the unit goes into the quilt, leaving 4 inches.

The American Patchwork & Quilting quarter-inch-seam guide explains why a consistent seam matters. Thread and pressing can change your result, so sew a test unit and check it against the pattern before you cut all your scraps.

Some methods start oversized and trim later, so a square that fits one pattern may be too small for another. Triangle units need the starting sizes from your pattern; the simple square math here doesn't apply to them.

Write a short list before you choose a pattern

This example compares two cuts: 2 1/2-inch squares for four-patches and 4 1/2-inch squares for plain blocks. Every size in the table is a measured clean rectangle, with selvage and damage already left out.

GroupPiecesClean size of eachFirst sort
A42 1/2 x 10 inNarrow strips
B33 1/2 x 7 inNarrow rectangles
C25 x 5 inWide pieces
D62 1/2 x 2 1/2 inReady small squares
E14 1/2 x 9 inWide rectangle
F12 1/4 x 6 inToo narrow for these cuts

Group F might come from a larger, irregular scrap. The list records its clean rectangle rather than its outline. "Too narrow" only means it won't give these two cuts; it may still suit improv or foundation piecing.

To count squares in a rectangle, count how many fit across the width and how many fit along the length, using whole numbers only. Multiply the two. That's how many squares you get from straight rows.

Group2 1/2-inch cuts4 1/2-inch cutsHow to use it
A16 total0Four small squares per strip
B6 total0Two small squares per rectangle
C8 total2 totalSmall or large cuts
D6 total0Use the squares as they are
E3 total2 totalSmall or large cuts
F00Leave out of this project

For groups C and E, the two columns are either/or. You can't add them together. Cutting a 5-inch square into four 2 1/2-inch squares uses up the fabric that would have made one 4 1/2-inch square.

Two separate cutting options for one five-inch square: four two-and-a-half-inch squares, or one four-and-a-half-inch square with narrow leftovers
Two ways to cut the same 5-inch square, drawn at exact size: four 2 1/2-inch squares for a four-patch, or one 4 1/2-inch square. You get one or the other.

Assign the pieces, then pick a project

Say you want a small study with five four-patches and four plain squares, all finishing at 4 inches. That takes 20 small squares and four large squares. Set three by three, they finish at 12 x 12 inches before borders, or 12 1/2 x 12 1/2 inches unfinished.

Assign each cut to a group:

You needFromCutsLeft over
20 small squaresA plus D16 from A; 4 from D2 squares from D
4 large squaresC plus E2 from C; 2 from ENarrow trim from C
SpareBNone yetAll 3 rectangles

This plan uses each group once. It keeps all of B for a test unit or a recut, instead of cutting it right away. The two spare D squares can't make another four-patch on their own; that takes four.

Leave room for a mistake. The design needs exactly 20 small and four large squares. Sew a test unit from the spare fabric, then recount. If one large piece turns out to be flawed, you're short on large squares even though small scraps remain.

Now check real patterns against your list. Look at every piece, not just the main square size. Background rectangles, setting triangles, borders and binding may need fabric that isn't in these groups. Our quilt design guide helps turn an idea into a planned top, and the backing and binding guide covers the finishing fabric.

Note why a piece is left out

Write a short reason beside each piece you leave out: too narrow, wrong fiber, a stain where the cut would go, unclear grain, or a motif you're saving. Then a later recount won't quietly put it back.

Before you swap one scrap for another, check the cut size again. A longer strip can replace a shorter one only if it's wide enough. A large print may have enough fabric but not the motif where you want it. Fiber and motif are separate checks from size.

Your next step

Pick one pattern you'd like to make, write down its cut sizes, and measure one bin of scraps against them. Then lay out colors with our scrappy quilt tips. Update your list whenever you cut, test, reject or save a piece, so the next pattern starts from fabric you know you have.

To decide what to do with future leftovers, set up a scrap cutting system: choose a few standard cuts from the patterns you use, keep useful lengths whole and set a limit on prepared pieces.

The free printable Scrap-Buster Quilt Guide has the sorting bins, standard cuts and piece counts from common scrap sizes, plus eight scrap quilt ideas, with no sign-up.

Free patterns to try

Printable PDF patterns with cutting charts and diagrams, free to download.

Browse all 330+ free patterns

Plan your next quilt

Lay out blocks and try colors in QuiltLab's grid editor before you cut.

Free forever, no card needed.

Get quilting tips by email

QuiltLab updates, tips and quilting inspiration. Unsubscribe anytime.

More in Quilt design and color →